Maxx Crosby or Trey Hendrickson — Who Should the Cowboys Break the Bank For?
Life After Micah Parsons — Should the Cowboys Go All-In on Maxx Crosby or Trey Hendrickson?
Micah Parsons is no longer a Dallas Cowboy. And instantly, a massive void appeared — not only in pass-rushing production, but in leadership, identity, and the fear he brought to every quarterback in the league.
If Dallas truly wants to stay in the Super Bowl conversation, they must find a new defensive cornerstone to build around.
Two names rise above the rest: Maxx Crosby of the Las Vegas Raiders and Trey Hendrickson of the Cincinnati Bengals.
But who is the better fit for the post-Parsons Cowboys?
✅ 1. Why Dallas Can’t Stay Still
-
Parsons accounted for 31% of the Cowboys’ total defensive pressures last season.
Dallas went from being a defense-led football team to facing an identity crisis.
In an NFC stacked with elite pass-rushers (Nick Bosa, Aidan Hutchinson, Haason Reddick), the Cowboys can’t afford to walk into 2025 without a replacement.
⚔️ 2. Maxx Crosby vs. Trey Hendrickson — Side-by-Side Breakdown
| Category | Maxx Crosby | Trey Hendrickson |
|---|---|---|
| 2024 Sacks | 14.5 | 17.5 |
| Pressure Rate | 13.8% | 14.3% |
| Play Style | relentless, high-motor, emotional leader | technical, efficient, quiet |
| Best Scheme Fit | Hybrid 3-4 / 4-3 | Pure 4-3 EDGE |
| Leadership | vocal, alpha mentality | leads by example |
| Run Defense & Pursuit | High impact all over the field | More pass-rush focused |
| Replacing Parsons’ impact | 85–90% (on-field + emotional) | 70–75% (elite sacks, less chaos) |
💥 3. Maxx Crosby — The Chaos Machine Dallas Is Missing
If Dallas wants someone who can replace Parsons not just as a pass-rusher, but as the emotional engine of the defense, Maxx Crosby is the answer.
Why he’s the best fit:
-
Leads the NFL in defensive snaps for three straight years — unmatched durability and motor.
Generates pressure from every alignment — inside, outside, stunts, blitzes.
Brings a “dog mentality” — the exact emotional edge Dallas lost when Parsons left.
Fits in both Dan Quinn’s old hybrid defense and Mike Zimmer’s current system.
The downside:
-
Raiders won’t let him go cheap. It will require massive draft capital and cap space.
⚡ 4. Trey Hendrickson — The Smart, Efficient Option
If Dallas prefers a safer, cost-effective, plug-and-play pass rusher, Trey Hendrickson is a very real solution.
Strengths:
-
Pass-rush win rate on par with Myles Garrett — but massively underrated by media.
Perfect fit for a 4-3 system — can start Day 1 without scheme adjustments.
Bengals were reportedly willing to negotiate his trade value in the past.
Weaknesses:
-
Not a locker-room alpha.
Less versatile — not as active in run defense or sideline-to-sideline pursuit.
Doesn’t strike fear into offensive coordinators the way Parsons or Crosby does.
🎯 5. So… Who Fits the Cowboys Better?
| If the Cowboys want… | Best Choice |
|---|---|
| A new face of the defense after Parsons | Maxx Crosby |
| Pure sack production at a lower cost | Trey Hendrickson |
| Leadership, fire, and a cultural reset | Maxx Crosby |
| Keep draft picks and fill the EDGE spot quietly | Trey Hendrickson |
✅ Final Verdict
Trey Hendrickson is the logical move.
But Maxx Crosby is the franchise-changing move.
Micah Parsons is gone. Dallas doesn’t just need a replacement — they need a new identity, a new defensive heartbeat.
And if Jerry Jones truly wants to win now, going all-in for Maxx Crosby might be the boldest — and most unforgettable — decision he could make.
May You Like
Latest Posts
Popular Posts
