Top 9 Players Who Could Join the Eagles This Season: Who's the Perfect Fit?

As the 2025 NFL season approaches, the Philadelphia Eagles are aiming to return to dominance after an inconsistent year. With a solid core in place, adding one more star — especially from the top 9 fantasy football performers of 2024 — could give them the boost they need to contend again. Below is a breakdown of 9 top fantasy players who could (or should) join the Eagles, along with an analysis of how each player fits or doesn’t fit into Philly’s current setup.

1. Lamar Jackson (QB – Ravens)

PPG: 25.32

Fit:
Jackson is the reigning MVP and a true dual-threat QB who can win games with both his legs and his arm. If the Eagles want to completely reset their offensive identity, Jackson would be a bold “win-now” move.

Not a Fit:
The Eagles already have Jalen Hurts, who plays a similar style. Bringing in Jackson could cause massive disruption to the current system. Plus, the cost — both financially and in trade assets — would be extremely high.

2. Ja’Marr Chase (WR – Bengals)

PPG: 23.71

Fit:
Even with A.J. Brown and DeVonta Smith, Chase is a game-changer — a true WR1 who would elevate the receiving corps to perhaps the best in the league. He’s a matchup nightmare and consistent fantasy powerhouse.

Not a Fit:
Salary cap issues and target distribution concerns arise. Chase would need a high target share, which could cause friction with existing WRs.

3. Josh Allen (QB – Bills)

PPG: 22.3

Fit:
Allen is the prototype of the modern quarterback: strong, mobile, and capable of dominating with his deep throws. If the Eagles ever wanted a complete overhaul at QB, Allen would be a dream option.

Not a Fit:
As with Jackson, the presence of Hurts makes this unlikely. Allen is the face of the Bills and likely untouchable in trade talks.

4. Saquon Barkley (RB – Eagles)

PPG: 22.21

ALREADY AN EAGLE – AND A PERFECT FIT
Barkley proved his elite talent last season and was a fantastic signing. His five 30+ point games show how well he complements the Eagles’ run-pass option system. He’s already a core piece of their offense.

5. Joe Burrow (QB – Bengals)

PPG: 21.93

Fit:
Burrow is a calm, smart pocket passer who brings precision and rhythm to an offense. He could be a long-term option if the Eagles decide to shift away from Hurts' dual-threat style.

Not a Fit:
Burrow’s style would require the offense to be rebuilt around him. He’s not as mobile as Hurts, which limits play-action and designed QB runs.

6. Baker Mayfield (QB – Buccaneers)

PPG: 21.52

Fit:
A solid backup option who brings leadership and consistency. Mayfield could push Hurts to improve or step in when needed without drastically changing the offense.

Not a Fit:
He’s not good enough to fully replace Hurts and would only make sense as a high-end backup, which may not be worth the cost.

7. Jahmyr Gibbs (RB – Lions)

PPG: 21.35

Fit:
Gibbs adds explosiveness as a pass-catching back and would shine in outside zones and screens. He could complement Barkley or step in if injuries arise.

Not a Fit:
Gibbs and Barkley have overlapping roles. It doesn’t make sense to spend big on another elite RB when the Eagles have other positional needs like WR3 or cornerback.

8. Jalen Hurts (QB – Eagles)

PPG: 21.01

ALREADY AN EAGLE
Though he had some ups and downs last season, Hurts remains a top-tier fantasy and real-life QB. With Barkley behind him, Hurts can focus on refining his decision-making and rediscovering his MVP-caliber form.

9. Jayden Daniels (QB – Commanders)

PPG: 20.93

Fit:
Daniels is a young, dynamic dual-threat QB who could develop well in a system like Philly’s. A smart investment for the future if Hurts’ form declines.

Not a Fit:
He’s a rookie with a divisional rival (Commanders), making any trade nearly impossible. The Eagles also don’t need another developmental QB right now.

Conclusion

While elite names like Lamar Jackson, Joe Burrow, and Ja’Marr Chase are enticing, the Eagles would be wise to consider practical and cost-effective options like Gibbs (for depth at RB) or Mayfield (as a high-end QB2) instead.

With Saquon Barkley and Jalen Hurts already in place, Philadelphia’s offense is in a strong position. Future additions should be based on financial realism and system fit, not star power alone.

Disclaimer: All information above is for discussion and reference purposes only. Nothing in this article confirms any actual transfer or transaction.