The Burned Letter – The Secret That Almost Made the Bills’ Head Coach Walk Away Forever

Buffalo, New York — When Sean McDermott walked out of the Highmark Stadium tunnel after the 28-21 win over the Chiefs, he raised his fist and smiled quietly. No one knew that just a year earlier, he had sat in that same office, writing a letter that would have ended his coaching career.

February 2024. The night after the crushing Super Bowl loss.
Buffalo was buried in snow, and McDermott sat alone under the yellow light. On his desk was a folded sheet of paper, the pen still wet with ink. The first three words read:
“To the Buffalo Bills…”

He wrote for two hours — every line heavier than the last. He wrote about the pressure, the sleepless nights, the feeling of failure even after giving everything he had. When he finished, McDermott folded it, tucked it into the drawer, and sighed — like a man letting go of a burden.

The next morning, the letter was gone.

Jamie McDermott had found it. She said nothing at first. That evening, when Sean came home, drained and silent, she held it out.
“When did you write this?” she asked softly.
Sean stared at the floor, silent.
“You’re really going to walk away? After everything we’ve fought for?”

McDermott looked up, eyes red.
“I’ve got nothing left to prove. I failed — the team, the fans, myself.”

Jamie’s voice cut through the air, calm but sharp.
“No, Sean. You didn’t fail. You’re just scared.”

She took the letter, walked out to the backyard. The wind was cold, snow drifting down. Jamie struck a match, and the paper caught fire.
“You’re not allowed to quit — not while you’re still breathing, and not while this team still believes in you.”
“What are you doing?” Sean asked, voice breaking.
“I’m saving you from yourself,” she said. “If you love this game like I know you do — you’ll be back on that field tomorrow.”

That night, Sean didn’t sleep. He watched the snow bury the backyard.
At 5 a.m., he got up, grabbed his playbook, and drove back to the practice field. No explanation. No drama. Just resolve.

When the Bills opened the 2025 season, no one knew what had happened. But something in McDermott’s eyes had changed — calmer, deeper. He was no longer driven by fear of failure, but by faith in something stronger.

After the win against the Chiefs in Week 9, a reporter asked,
“Coach, what kept you from giving up?”
McDermott paused, smiled faintly, and said,
“Because she believed in me… when I didn’t believe in myself.”

Josh Allen later said, “When he said that, the room went completely silent. We all knew he was talking about Jamie.”
Another assistant added, “Sometimes, a coach’s biggest victory doesn’t happen on the field — it happens at home.”

The letter was never found again.
Only a small burn mark remains on the frame of a photo on Sean’s desk — a picture of him and Jamie from high school.
Etched faintly on the back are the words:
“Don’t give up yet.”