Logo

Steelers Defense Is the NFL’s Most Expensive - But Not the Most Effective

The Pittsburgh Steelers are making headlines for all the wrong reasons when it comes to their defense. Despite investing more money into the unit than any other team in the NFL — a staggering $143 million according to OverTheCap — the returns on that investment have been underwhelming.

Heading into the 2025 season, Pittsburgh boasts the league’s most expensive defense, yet their on-field performance has failed to justify the price tag. For a franchise known for its defensive legacy, the numbers are beginning to raise red flags.


🔹 Big Names, Bigger Contracts

Article image

It’s easy to see where the money’s going. T.J. Watt, Minkah Fitzpatrick, Patrick Queen, and Cameron Heyward account for a massive portion of the Steelers’ salary cap. These are household names, former All-Pros, and locker room leaders — but their collective impact hasn’t translated into elite defensive metrics.

In 2024, the Steelers defense ranked:

  • 19th in points allowed per game

  • 12th in total yards allowed

  • Middle of the pack in takeaways and sacks

  • Those aren’t the numbers you expect from a unit that commands nearly two-thirds of the team’s cap on defense alone.


    🔹 Where Is the Disconnect?

    PHOTOS: Defensive Line 2022 highlights

    Defensive coordinator Teryl Austin and head coach Mike Tomlin have built a system that prioritizes aggressive edge rushers, deep safeties, and rotational depth. But consistency has been a major issue.

    Despite splash plays from Watt and Fitzpatrick, the defense often faltered in key moments — especially in third-down situations and late-game drives.

    “It’s not just about money,” one AFC executive told Steelers Depot. “You have to get the return — and right now, Pittsburgh isn’t.”

    The addition of Patrick Queen was supposed to boost speed and versatility, but miscommunications and breakdowns in coverage continued to plague the team throughout the season.


    🔹 A Make-or-Break Year Ahead?

    PHOTOS: Defensive Line 2022 highlights

    As the Steelers look to contend with Aaron Rodgers under center, all eyes are on whether the defense can finally match its payroll in production. Pittsburgh has a mix of veterans and rising talents, but questions linger about durability, depth, and scheme fit.

    With Cameron Heyward aging, T.J. Watt seeking a $40 million/year extension, and younger players needing to step up, 2025 could determine the future structure of the unit.


    🔵 More to Read:

    • NFL Salary Cap Explained: Why Pittsburgh’s Defense Dominates the Payroll

  • Fantasy Football Sleepers 2025: Steelers IDPs to Watch

  • NFL Super Bowl Odds: Can Pittsburgh Compete with a Lopsided Cap Structure?

  • Best NFL Betting Apps to Wager on Defensive Props This Season

  • T.J. Watt Contract Watch: What His Holdout Means for the Team

  • Tre'von Moehrig Lavishes Praise on the One Who Replaced Him in His Absence
    Can you believe it? A veteran star of the Carolina Panthers, Tre'von Moehrig, was suspended for a notorious "punch below the belt," but instead of being jealous, he's showering praise on his "replacement"! What's going on with this team? Read now for the "hot off the press" details from Week 13! The Carolina Panthers just caused an earthquake by defeating the Los Angeles Rams in Week 13, despite missing a slew of key players. Under the "wizardry" of head coach Dave Canales, the team showcased incredible resilience. But the real spotlight belongs to Tre'von Moehrig – the Panthers' top safety, who's sidelined due to a suspension after punching wide receiver Jauan Jennings from the San Francisco 49ers below the belt. Yet, instead of sulking, Moehrig watched from home and... "went wild" over the performance of the rookie who stepped in for him! That's none other than Lathan Ransom, the young gun selected in the 4th round of the draft, who "stole" Moehrig's spot and turned it into his own stage. Ransom not only led the team with 11 tackles but also made his mark with a "top-notch" sack! Moehrig, with his wealth of experience, couldn't hide his excitement: "Man, I was hype (for Lathan Ransom's sack). I could see it all as the play was happening. I was like, Oh, there you go. I could see it all the way. So I was happy for him to get his first sack. He had a great game, and I'm just excited. Sky's the limit for him." (Translation: "Oh man, I was so hyped (for Lathan Ransom's sack). I could see everything as the play unfolded. I was like, Oh, there you go. I saw it all the way. So I was happy for him to get his first sack. He had a great game, and I'm just excited. The sky's the limit for him." This "sweet as honey" praise from Moehrig not only affirms Ransom's talent but also raises the question: Is this "replacement" threatening the starting positions of Moehrig and Nick Scott – the current starting safety duo? Panthers fans have been "whispering" about this for a while, after witnessing Ransom shine in summer practices and his flashy cameo appearances. With this impressive performance, Ransom is sure to get more opportunities, especially as the Panthers are "heating up" in the race for the NFC South championship! At 23 years old, Ransom is seen as a "rough diamond" with explosive potential, thanks to the Panthers' sharp personnel strategy. And Moehrig? This guy was signed as a "bargain" from the free agent market, and his leadership and positive attitude have completely transformed the team's defense in just his first season. That influence is spreading strongly to Ransom – the kid who shares many similarities and is gradually "transforming" into a future star. But that's not all – the lesson from Moehrig is accelerating the "youth revolution" at the Panthers! With this public praise, Moehrig isn't just acknowledging Ransom's growth but also igniting ambition for the entire team. Will the Panthers continue to "soar high" with this new generation? Don't miss out – follow now for the next drama in the NFL!