Logo

Packers’ Former First-Round Pick Projected for Surprise Week 1 Benching

In a surprising projection by Bleacher Report, Green Bay Packers linebacker Quay Walker, a former first-round draft pick, is predicted to be sidelined in favor of Isaiah McDuffie for the starting lineup in Week 1 of the 2025 NFL season.

Selected 22nd overall in the 2022 NFL Draft, Walker was expected to become a cornerstone of the Packers’ defense. However, Bleacher Report forecasts that McDuffie, a sixth-round pick (220th overall) in 2021, will take his spot. This prediction is a shock, given Walker’s status as a high draft investment for Green Bay.

Article image

Why This Projection?

Several factors contribute to this bold forecast:

  • Walker’s Inconsistent Performance: Over three seasons, Walker has struggled to meet expectations. His rookie year in 2022 was marred by inconsistency and two ejections, drawing criticism from fans and analysts alike.
  • McDuffie’s Emergence: Isaiah McDuffie has shown significant improvement, particularly in defensive reliability and consistency. He is seen as a better fit for the new 4-3 defensive scheme implemented by defensive coordinator Jeff Hafley.
  • Scheme Change: The Packers’ shift to a 4-3 defense requires linebackers with strong coverage skills, and McDuffie appears to align more closely with these demands compared to Walker.

Fan Reaction

The projection isn’t entirely surprising to some Packers fans. During the previous season, certain fans called for McDuffie to replace Walker at times due to the latter’s uneven play. Still, the idea of a first-round pick being benched remains a contentious topic and is likely to spark debate.

Article image

Packers’ Roster Context

Following the 2025 free agency period and NFL Draft, the Packers did not significantly bolster their linebacker depth. One notable addition is Collin Oliver, a hybrid linebacker/edge rusher from Oklahoma State, but the team largely relies on its current roster. The departure of Eric Wilson to the Minnesota Vikings has heightened the focus on the competition between Walker and McDuffie. Meanwhile, De’Vondre Campbell remains a key figure in the defensive unit.

Implications for the Season

If Bleacher Report’s prediction holds true and Walker is benched, it would signal that the Packers are prioritizing current performance over pedigree or long-term potential. Such a move could put immense pressure on Walker to reclaim his role or risk being traded, much like Eric Stokes, another former first-round pick who was previously demoted from the starting lineup.

0 views
49ers Superstar QB Returns from Injury and Leaves Cardinals Head Coach in Shock: "We Were Completely Outmatched"
In their Week 11 NFL 2025 matchup, the San Francisco 49ers cruised past the Arizona Cardinals with a commanding 41 to 22 victory at State Farm Stadium, marking the triumphant return of quarterback Brock Purdy. This was Purdy’s first appearance since September 28 after dealing with a turf toe injury. He completed 19 of 26 passes for 200 yards, three touchdowns, and no interceptions. Christian McCaffrey once again proved his superstar value with three touchdowns (two rushing and one receiving), racking up 81 rushing yards and 121 total yards from scrimmage. Tight end George Kittle also made his presence felt with six catches for 67 yards and two touchdowns. While the 49ers controlled most of the game, the Cardinals had a few notable bright spots. Quarterback Jacoby Brissett delivered a career performance, completing 47 of 57 passes for 452 yards, two touchdowns, and two interceptions. Wide receivers Michael Wilson (15 catches for 185 yards) and Trey McBride (10 catches for 115 yards) were Brissett’s top targets in the contest. However, the Cardinals sabotaged themselves with a franchise-record 17 penalties, costing them a total of 130 yards. This broke a team record that had stood since 1936. A 60-yard touchdown run by Bam Knight was nullified due to a holding call. Additionally, Arizona fumbled at the goal line early in the fourth quarter when Elijah Higgins lost the ball. Kicker Eddy Piñeiro added three field goals for the 49ers (from 47, 48, and 47 yards), extending his streak to 22 consecutive successful kicks. Notably, he was also the one who nailed the game-winning 35-yard field goal in Week 3 when the 49ers edged out the Cardinals 16 to 15. With this victory, the 49ers improve to 7 and 4 and remain firmly in the hunt for an NFC playoff spot although they still sit eighth in the conference standings. 🗓️ Upcoming Games for the 49ers: Monday, Nov 24 vs Carolina Panthers at 5:15 PM PT Sunday, Nov 30 at Cleveland Browns at 10:00 AM PT Sunday, Dec 7 BYE WEEK Sunday, Dec 14 vs Tennessee Titans at 1:25 PM PT Monday, Dec 22 at Indianapolis Colts at 5:15 PM PT 🎙️ Cardinals Head Coach Jonathan Gannon Reacts: "I have to admit today we were completely outmatched. They played with speed, discipline, and precision that we simply couldn’t match. Brock Purdy returned and ran the game like a machine, and their offense gave us no room to adjust or breathe. You can’t just blame technical errors or individual mistakes. This was a breakdown of our entire system. We need to take a hard look at ourselves from the meeting rooms to the field and we must respond as one unified team if we want to improve."