Eagles and Broncos Submit 10GB of Evidence Files to the NFL, Claim Over 10 Incorrect Calls That Affected Both Teams

In a rare move of unity between two rival organizations, the Philadelphia Eagles and Denver Broncos have jointly submitted a 10-gigabyte evidence package to the NFL league office, alleging that more than ten officiating errors during their Week 5 matchup significantly altered the course of the game.

According to The Athletic and multiple sources close to both teams, the file includes slow-motion video breakdowns, All-22 footage, referee mic recordings, and statistical officiating analyses. Both franchises claim the officiating inconsistencies were so severe that they impacted drives, momentum, and ultimately, the outcome of the game — which ended in a controversial 21-17 win for Denver.

Among the calls under review are several No-Call Defensive Pass Interference plays, picked-up flags, a questionable Unnecessary Roughness penalty, and multiple Illegal Shift and Intentional Grounding rulings that left players, coaches, and analysts puzzled.

Replay footage submitted by both teams reportedly shows that similar contact or movement was judged differently depending on which team committed it.
In one example, Eagles TE Dallas Goedert was visibly pulled by Broncos safety JL Skinner in the game’s final seconds — no flag was thrown. Yet earlier in the game, a nearly identical situation involving a Broncos receiver resulted in a penalty.

Officials led by referee Adrian Hill have since defended their performance, calling the game’s contact “mutual” and the penalties “subjective.” However, experts, former referees, and several media outlets including CBS Sports and Pro Football Focus have called the officiating “inconsistent and below professional standard.”

In a statement during his post-practice press conference, Eagles head coach Nick Sirianni expressed frustration but kept his tone professional:

“Both teams sat down and went over everything together. We agreed — there were too many mistakes. Win or lose, we can’t allow these errors to keep happening. My players fight too hard to have the game decided by something outside their control. They deserve fairness.”

The Broncos have also confirmed their participation in the report submission. A team source told ESPN that head coach Sean Payton “fully supports the league reviewing every second of that tape,” insisting that “it’s about accountability, not excuses.”

Social media has erupted over the issue, with fans from both fanbases calling for transparency and disciplinary action against the officiating crew.
Several viral clips showing slowed-down footage of the controversial moments have gained millions of views under hashtags like #NFLRefs and #RiggedCalls.

The NFL Referee Association has yet to issue a formal comment, but insiders told NBC Sports that the league’s Officiating Command Center in New York is now conducting a full audit of the Week 5 game film. Depending on findings, the officiating crew may face internal review or temporary suspension.

As one Eagles staffer reportedly told The Inquirer:

“It’s not about blaming. It’s about protecting the integrity of the game. If we can’t trust the calls, we can’t trust the results.”

The controversy continues to grow, and both fanbases — though rivals on the field — appear united in one message to the league: it’s time for accountability