Are the Cowboys’ Offensive Line Critics Getting It Wrong in 2025?

Many experts call the Cowboys' offensive line "shaky," but that might be a rushed judgment.
While Tyron Smith’s departure raised red flags, Dallas quietly rebuilt with intention. First-round pick Tyler Guyton has elite athleticism and a frame built for protecting the edge. Tyler Smith is quickly turning into a Pro Bowl-caliber guard, and Tyler Booker, the 12th overall pick in 2025, has taken over at right guard following Zack Martin’s retirement; Booker, who had zero sacks in 395 pass-protection snaps at Alabama, is expected to become the new mainstay with his strength and aggressive style of play. What seems like instability is actually calculated retooling.

Guyton has already drawn praise for his footwork and adaptability in OTAs. Behind him, the coaching staff is betting big on in-house development rather than overpaying for aging free agents. Conor Riley’s return as OL coach has brought a sense of cohesion and system familiarity. Cowboys aren’t just plugging holes—they’re building sustainability.

“You think we’re broken? Keep watching,” Tyler Smith said in minicamp with a grin. NFL Network’s Brian Baldinger added, “This line might surprise everyone by Week 4.” Confidence is quietly brewing in Dallas, and the front office seems comfortable playing the long game.

Come September, the so-called weakness might just be the biggest surprise.
If Dak Prescott gets 2.7+ seconds in the pocket, this offense has the weapons to torch defenses. With CeeDee Lamb, George Pickens, and Jake Ferguson all healthy, the trenches might no longer be the concern—but the catalyst.